Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Karla McLaren, M.Ed.'s avatar

Thanks so much for this, Dan. The dangers of meditation -- especially for people who have experienced trauma, anxiety intensities, and recurrent episodes of panic (notice that I'm not calling any of these things disorders) -- has been well documented, but silenced, ignored, or shouted down.

And the ethical lapses involved in selling mindfulness to captive audiences in the workplace, schools, prisons, and other high-control organizations are also not being addressed with enough seriousness.

If something is powerful, it can be powerfully healing and also powerfully harmful.

I grew up in the meditation and yoga cultures and saw so much trouble there that, as a teen, I developed my own practices that don't lead to dissociation, depersonalization, or emotional disruptions. I thought I was being impertinent, but i really couldn't tolerate meditation or the culture of certainty around it.

I see now that I had a pretty good idea! Thanks for telling your story. I'm certain that people will tell you that you weren't doing meditation right, but that's a part of the silencing culture. These negative effects are real and not disclosed, which leads to unnecessary suffering. I don't think Buddha would like that!

Expand full comment
Shekinah's avatar

Thank you Dan. I really resonated with your experience after having a practically rough experience and reintegration afterwards as a new practioner at a meditation center and seeing not only myself but other meditators dismissed, minimized, blamed and shamed for their challenges including anxiety attacks, PTSD, and psychosis. I really resonated with the anger you expressed in saying "What kind of fucking person would go through this and not warn others of the risks?" And with the loss of faith you described not so much in Buddhism, but in people's ability to act in accordance with their professed values. Compassion and wisdom are often taught as values with Buddhism and meditation is taught a pathway for developing theses qualities. The way in which I have experienced and you have described teachers teaching intensive meditation and treat the real suffering of students strikes me as deeply at odd with these values. You mentioned transparency, honesty, humility as values within religion but these same values are essential to all types of organization including the business and nonprofit models many monasteries use. I have been researching and looking at other monasteries, and wondering what it would look like to find a place that is truly ethical and accountable for their full impact, including the negative. The question of who a teacher is accountabile to has become very important to me. Thank you also for sharing so many great resources here. Meditation for me these days is very hard- as what once brought relaxation now brings tension to my body. However, sitting outside and breathing deeply, allowing my focus to shift to noticing the colors, textures, movements around me in nature allows me to find a place of tranquility when focused breath meditation becomes to much. I have also returned to dancing and spend more time in the earth based practices that feel more resonate for me. Different postures while meditating other then sitting have also helped enter more of a state of being, rather than fighting patterns of thinking. I am happy to hear that you have reclaimed the parts of your identity that are essential, may you continue to grow in and blossom in your essence as the process of healing continues.I am also glad to hear you are going to be teaching mindfulness with transparency and with the knowledge and experience you've gained. Trauma-informed mindfulness instructors are very much needed as are those who will share these concerns with both students and other instructors. Blessings to you on your journey, may you be supported and bring forth your gifts and experience in a way that benefits many beings. With Gratitude,

Shekinah

Expand full comment
72 more comments...